I have an obsession. Well, more than one, but this one is reading-related. It’s called: reading Goodreads reviews and try to decide if I might like a book based upon the rating-system. It got ugly, guys, because while it has been helpful to me in more than one case, it’s also driving me mad, because how can I trust reviews when they’re not fair?


I strongly believe that rating books is not about rating books. There, I said it. I think your mind plays tricks while reading a book, or any other text, because it isn’t humanly possible to read words and not make a whole bunch of associations. Everyone does it, and therefore, reading is about those associations, and about your feelings.

It’s a good thing that most writers, because they are human too, know that the words they write down aren’t plain words that they put together to form a sentence, to form a paragraph, to form a chapter, to form a book. So writers, smart asses as they are, write down their words in such a way that it makes you laugh, or cry, or get angry, or sometimes all at the same time.

Feeling those, sometimes strong, emotions towards a story provokes thought in a reader’s mind. They start to think and this is where they can’t be trusted anymore around a rating-system. Your experience starts to blur your judgement and as a result it is hard to think about how well written a story is.*

I won’t say I haven’t been guilty to low- or high-rating a book because of other reasons than it being a bad or a good book. It happened to me during the last book club meeting where we discussed Lobsters by Tom Ellen and Lucy Ivison, that I began to wonder if I really thought the book was bad or that it was just not a story that I generally like. Now, a few weeks since, I have come to the conclusion that I have been too harsh – Lobsters may not have been the best book ever written, but it was funny enough and also a quick read which I think would have appreciated more if I had been looking for that kind of books at the time.

I think that reading a book at the right time and place, and with an open mind towards a book are the most important rules for writing a more fair review. June might not have been the right time for me to read Lobsters, but it certainly was the right time for me to read a whole bunch of other books.

* Of course the exception here is that sometimes a book can be written so badly, that all you can think about is how badly it is written.


Francisca is a YA book clubber looking to diversify her reading. She studied history, loves her guinea pigs and the size of her TBR pile will make you feel less bad about your own.

Comments are closed.