“You’re the girl who called me an asshole the first time we spoke. The girl who tried to pay for lunch even after you learned I have more money than God. You’re the girl that I–” Noah stopped, then took a step closer to me. “You are my girl.”


What is this book about?

Mara Dyer is suffering from memory loss after a heavy accident in an abandoned hospital. She was sneakily hanging out with her friends while the building collapsed and everyone, except for her, died. In one night she lost her boyfriend, best friend and a somewhat friend, but something doesn’t seem to add up. How was Mara mostly unharmed? She moves to a different city and a different school, to try and forget about it, but when supernatural-type things start happening around her, she starts to second guess the events of that night.

Why is it boring?

This is part 1 in a trilogy and although a mystery is set up, I found myself not caring all that much about it. Mara starts out the book stating that it isn’t actually her name and that her lawyer told her to pick another name, because of a supernatural killer being on the loose, and I figured that the book was going to throw me for a loop about who it would be. Any of the characters seemed creepy enough to be supernatural homicidal maniacs, so I was curious to see how this went along. But after the first quarter of the book, i got too annoyed with everyone to actually care. This is not a mystery novel, people. It’s romance.

Who would you recommend it to?

I’m going to make myself immensely unpopular by saying this, but I don’t like all these books masquerading as fantasy/mystery/paranormal-stuff, while they are actually romance novels. Apparently, I’m not a fan on those. This book reminded me of Shatter Me, but also The Mortal Instruments series in that aspect. The romance and the swooning has the upper hand over the mystery and bad-assery.

Why should I read it if it’s boring?!

I stumbled upon this series after reading an interesting article written by the author. She seemed to me a pretty interesting lady, so I figured I’d give her book a try. I had wanted to write a Boring Series Recommendation for all three books, but after one I could not continue. I knew I would not enjoy this series, as these type of romance novels are simply not for me. Especially the female characters in these books annoy me. The entire book is simply centered around Mara and a hot boy with a British accent. He’s arrogant and of course Mara falls head over heels for this rich, obnoxious, Christian-Grey-in-the-making.  Mara is supposed to be pretty bad ass with her supernatural abilities, but she lets Noah boss her around like you wouldn’t believe. Besides my feminist bitching, I also have some plot-related difficulties. The story feels rushed and stalled at the same time. People get murdered left and right, but there is no good reason for any of this, besides filling up the book. Mara and boy toy Noah go on meaningless dates, fall in love after meeting each other thrice and then decide to murder someone to fix the whole thing. And talking about murdering someone… That ending! I know I hate most endings, but this one was confusing and of course it had to be a cliffhanger. It pulled a Pretty Little Liars on me, making me want to know what will happen next without actually being interested in the story. Part 1 can definitely not stand on it’s own and will really need part 2 and 3 to make sense. Almost nothing gets resolved in this book and I feel like it is going to string me along for another seven seasons.

Rating: 1,5/5

buy the book from The Book Depository, free delivery


Esmée de Heer is head honcho over at the Bored to Death book club website, writing the daily content and making sure the site stays up and running. She's one of the founding sisters of the book club and enjoys reading and giving unsolicited love advice.

Comments are closed.